Sebastian Mallaby of the Washington Post
wonders if the often tenuous relationship between Republican conservatives and libertarians has reached an ending point, and if there's an opportunity for them to align with the Democrats.
"Republicans are not merely failing to live up to their principles; the principles have altered. The party has been virtually cleaned out of the Northeast; it has suffered setbacks in the Mountain West; it increasingly reflects the values of its stronghold in the South. As a result, it has lost its libertarian tinge and grown more religious and traditionalist."
...as we've been saying.
"Would libertarians be more comfortable in the company of Democrats? On moral questions -- abortion, gay marriage, stem cell research -- clearly they would. But on economic issues, the answer is less obvious.
If Democrats can get over this nostalgia, there's a chance that liberaltarianism could work. For the time has passed when libertarians could seriously hope to cut government: Much of what could be deregulated has been, and the combination of demographics, defense costs and medical inflation leaves no scope for tax cuts. As Lindsey himself says, the ambition of realistic libertarians is not to shrink government but to contain it: to cut senseless spending such as the farm program and oil subsidies to make room for the inevitable expansion in areas such as health.
As it happens, this also describes a plausible agenda for the Democratic Party -- at least if it can shed the back-to-the-1950s yearnings of its reactionary left. Precisely because Democrats want government to provide social insurance against the volatility of globalization, the party has an interest in cutting unneeded federal spending. Precisely because entitlements are expanding so expensively, the party needs cost-saving ideas from anyone who has them -- including libertarians."
We saw the beginning of this realignment this past November, as Democrats made major gains in the West, where libertarianism has traditionally thrived. If Democrats can make the libertarians a permanent part of their coalition, it will continue to isolate the Republicans, not only geographically in the South but also ideologically with far-right Christian fundamentalists.
We should really be asking what the big deal was over the election we just had if we are only electing people who politicize, strategize, speak a good game, but get nothing done that helps most Americans.
